{
  "checked_on": "2026-10-14",
  "method": "Visual inspection of the four registered/polled sex counts on page 1 of each archived Form-47 scan; compared with the downloadable constituency CSV.",
  "numeric_corrections": false,
  "checks": [
    {
      "na": "NA-59",
      "constituency_name": "Talagang-cum-Chakwal",
      "election_year": 2024,
      "source_document": "ECP Form-47, NA-59.pdf, archived in Aiwan-e-Jamhoor sources/National Assembly 2024",
      "source_sha256": "15c1f8a63f29b73a8aea7964eeec5571b4e0f04db18756c2c7c75204371b19f6",
      "source_page": 1,
      "counts_read_from_scan": {
        "reg_male": 309180,
        "reg_female": 298660,
        "polled_male": 245082,
        "polled_female": 110504
      },
      "matches_downloadable_csv": true,
      "turnout_gap_pp": 42.268454,
      "decision": "Retain the printed counts; mark the unusual return and report exclusion sensitivity. Transcription verified; underlying source accuracy is not independently established."
    },
    {
      "na": "NA-186",
      "constituency_name": "Dera Ghazi Khan-III",
      "election_year": 2024,
      "source_document": "ECP Form-47, NA-186.pdf, archived in Aiwan-e-Jamhoor sources/National Assembly 2024",
      "source_sha256": "b3fa163b328f3a8739d694840b16a2feb14fcfd49e2a94dfdb89ef6f2982ca71",
      "source_page": 1,
      "counts_read_from_scan": {
        "reg_male": 210263,
        "reg_female": 176741,
        "polled_male": 149524,
        "polled_female": 62519
      },
      "matches_downloadable_csv": true,
      "turnout_gap_pp": 35.739615,
      "decision": "Retain the printed counts; mark the unusual return and report exclusion sensitivity. Transcription verified; underlying source accuracy is not independently established.",
      "other_source_inconsistency": "The scan prints 212043 for both total and valid votes and separately prints 4396 rejected votes. This does not reconcile. No replacement sex counts are inferred."
    },
    {
      "na": "NA-236",
      "constituency_name": "Karachi East-II",
      "election_year": 2024,
      "source_document": "ECP Form-47, NA-236.pdf, archived in Aiwan-e-Jamhoor sources/National Assembly 2024",
      "source_sha256": "3fb7f6312d7e4e738a7a1a9734bce472b2cbef31eaa8fd322e6a7170a3957843",
      "source_page": 1,
      "counts_read_from_scan": {
        "reg_male": 280363,
        "reg_female": 262046,
        "polled_male": 94059,
        "polled_female": 41156
      },
      "matches_downloadable_csv": true,
      "turnout_gap_pp": 17.843367,
      "decision": "Retain the printed counts; mark the unusual return and report exclusion sensitivity. Transcription verified; underlying source accuracy is not independently established."
    }
  ]
}