Cotton: n=671 districts=19 years=36 R2(within)=0.143 rain_julaug_10mm -1.81% per unit (SE 0.59, t=-3.1) Rice: n=1005 districts=27 years=39 R2(within)=0.029 rain_julaug_10mm -0.41% per unit (SE 0.15, t=-2.8) Maize: n=759 districts=20 years=39 R2(within)=0.014 rain_julaug_10mm +0.06% per unit (SE 0.17, t=+0.4) Sugarcane: n=963 districts=25 years=39 R2(within)=0.017 rain_julaug_10mm +0.21% per unit (SE 0.13, t=+1.6) Cotton ex 2022: n=653 districts=19 years=35 R2(within)=0.074 rain_julaug_10mm -1.39% per unit (SE 0.57, t=-2.4) Cotton ex 1983, 2022: n=634 districts=19 years=34 R2(within)=0.044 rain_julaug_10mm -0.80% per unit (SE 0.34, t=-2.3) Cotton rain x post-2010 interaction: base -1.31%/10mm, extra after 2010 -1.12 (SE 0.63, t=-1.8) Cotton (pooled, for scenario): n=671 districts=19 years=36 R2(within)=0.143 rain_julaug_10mm -1.81% per unit (SE 0.59, t=-3.1) Jul-Aug rain, complete cotton weather frame: 1981-2010 95.1 mm, 2015-2024 154.1 mm, shift +59.0 mm scenario yield effect of that shift (point): -10.2% scenario yield effect of that shift (low): -16.1% scenario yield effect of that shift (high): -3.8% ============================================================================== Checks after the Codex reviews of 11 November 2026 (review_checks_2026-11-11.py, complete run) ============================================================================== Cotton, all 19 units: n=671 units=19 years=36 | rain Jul-Aug -1.81%/10mm, SE 0.59; normal 95% [-2.97,-0.65]; t(G-1) 95% [-3.06,-0.57] wild cluster bootstrap (by unit, Rademacher, 1,999 draws): t=-3.06, p=0.000 units by province: {'BAHAWALNAGAR': 'Punjab', 'BAHAWALPUR': 'Punjab', 'DERA GHAZI KHAN': 'Punjab', 'FAISALABAD': 'Punjab', 'HYDERABAD': 'Sindh', 'JHANG': 'Punjab', 'KHAIRPUR': 'Sindh', 'LAYYAH': 'Punjab', 'MULTAN': 'Punjab', 'MUZAFFARGARH': 'Punjab', 'RAHIM YAR KHAN': 'Punjab', 'RAJANPUR': 'Punjab', 'SAHIWAL': 'Punjab', 'SANGHAR': 'Sindh', 'SHAHEED BENAZIRABAD': 'Sindh', 'SUKKUR': 'Sindh', 'THARPARKAR': 'Sindh', 'TOBA TEK SINGH': 'Punjab', 'VEHARI': 'Punjab'} Cotton, Punjab units only: n=465 units=13 years=36 | rain Jul-Aug -2.26%/10mm, SE 0.89; normal 95% [-4.01,-0.51]; t(G-1) 95% [-4.20,-0.31] wild cluster bootstrap (by unit, Rademacher, 1,999 draws): t=-2.53, p=0.015 Cotton, Sindh units only (6 clusters: bootstrap not informative): n=206 units=6 years=36 | rain Jul-Aug -1.22%/10mm, SE 0.61; normal 95% [-2.41,-0.02]; t(G-1) 95% [-2.78,+0.35] wild cluster bootstrap (by unit, Rademacher, 1,999 draws): t=-2.00, p=0.000 Cotton, Punjab units, excluding 1983 and 2022: n=440 units=13 years=34 | rain Jul-Aug -0.81%/10mm, SE 0.43; normal 95% [-1.66,+0.04]; t(G-1) 95% [-1.75,+0.14] wild cluster bootstrap (by unit, Rademacher, 1,999 draws): t=-1.86, p=0.150 Punjab units Jul-Aug rain: 1981-2010 92.2, 2015-2024 144.1 (+56%), ex 2022 132.4 Punjab scenario with Punjab coefficient, t(12): -11.0% [-19.6, -1.6] (shift 51.83 mm) Punjab scenario with Punjab ex-1983/2022 coefficient, t(12): -4.1% [-8.7, +0.7] coefficient intervals t(G-1): Punjab -2.26 [-4.20, -0.31]; Punjab ex -0.81 [-1.75, +0.14] rice t(26) interval: -0.41 [-0.72, -0.10] R2 within Punjab: see fit line above all-units scenario at -1.81: -10.1%; at -0.80 (ex 1983, 2022): -4.6% route A (modern>=20k, then merge): 19 ['BAHAWALNAGAR', 'BAHAWALPUR', 'DERA GHAZI KHAN', 'FAISALABAD', 'HYDERABAD', 'JHANG', 'KHAIRPUR', 'LAYYAH', 'MULTAN', 'MUZAFFARGARH', 'RAHIM YAR KHAN', 'RAJANPUR', 'SAHIWAL', 'SANGHAR', 'SHAHEED BENAZIRABAD', 'SUKKUR', 'THARPARKAR', 'TOBA TEK SINGH', 'VEHARI'] route B (merge, then >=20k): 19 difference: set() ============================================================================== Within-season check, 18 November 2026 (review_checks_2026-11-18.py) ============================================================================== Cotton, Punjab units, main model: n=465 | rain Jul-Aug -2.26%/10mm, two-way clustered SE 0.89, t(12) 95% [-4.20,-0.31] Cotton, Punjab units, adding year fixed effects: n=465 | rain Jul-Aug -0.81%/10mm, two-way clustered SE 0.74, t(12) 95% [-2.43,+0.81]